Contact Us/Help!
Handle:
Password:
Forget Your Password?    Join for FREE!
ocguy66
OC, CA
45 blogs/1904 comments
since Apr 26 2006

Level 5
AttributeLevel
Overall5
Safety5
Compliance5
Integrity5
Reliability5
Karma5
See Photo Albums
Car Buying - AAA, Costco
Feb 16 2019 03:13PM more by ocguy66
Tags: Orange County, Random (All tags)

Has anyone here used these services for a new car? Does it really make a difference versus haggling with the dealer?

      
There are 32 comments on this blog.
teeitup
Massachusetts
1017 blogs/14626 comments
since Jun 9 2007

Level 4
AttributeLevel
Overall4
Safety4
Compliance5
Integrity4
Reliability4
Karma4
See Photo Albums
Feb 16 2019 03:25PM     link to this

Do you haggle using a baseball bat?

(not used either service although I may try Costco next time)
ocguy66
OC, CA
45 blogs/1904 comments
since Apr 26 2006

Level 5
AttributeLevel
Overall5
Safety5
Compliance5
Integrity5
Reliability5
Karma5
See Photo Albums
Feb 16 2019 03:26PM     link to this

I usually go with tire iron, well because it’s there in the car already
billinirvine
Irvine, OC, CA
88 blogs/1903 comments
since Jan 25 2008

Level 3
AttributeLevel
Overall3
Safety3
Compliance4
Integrity3
Reliability3
Karma3
See Photo Albums
Feb 16 2019 03:56PM     link to this

Truecar. Look at the price spread. Shoot for your target.
Just don't sign up with your phone number or you'll get calls and emails for a year.
I've gotten two cars at the lowest sales price in California for that model.
ocguy66
OC, CA
45 blogs/1904 comments
since Apr 26 2006

Level 5
AttributeLevel
Overall5
Safety5
Compliance5
Integrity5
Reliability5
Karma5
See Photo Albums
Feb 16 2019 03:59PM     link to this

Cool. I will look at. Thanks.
Facephuckker
Austin, TX
149 blogs/9751 comments
since Sep 10 2009

Level 4
AttributeLevel
Overall4
Safety5
Compliance5
Integrity4
Reliability4
Karma4
See Photo Albums
Feb 16 2019 04:02PM     link to this

They�re all scams
True car, aaa,Costco, caravans, carmax

Negotiate yourself and don�t be afraid to walk
Don�t waste time with salesmen, go straight to the gsm
ocguy66
OC, CA
45 blogs/1904 comments
since Apr 26 2006

Level 5
AttributeLevel
Overall5
Safety5
Compliance5
Integrity5
Reliability5
Karma5
See Photo Albums
Feb 16 2019 04:52PM     link to this

Thanks phuckerface
ocguy66
OC, CA
45 blogs/1904 comments
since Apr 26 2006

Level 5
AttributeLevel
Overall5
Safety5
Compliance5
Integrity5
Reliability5
Karma5
See Photo Albums
Feb 16 2019 04:53PM     link to this

Uh... sorry about that
bwana
Santa Monica, LA, CA
155 blogs/6021 comments
since Jul 3 2007

Level 5
AttributeLevel
Overall5
Safety5
Compliance5
Integrity5
Reliability5
Karma5
See Photo Albums
Feb 16 2019 05:01PM     link to this

They all will give you good discounts,. You should check with the manufacturer's websites to see if they have any discount programs going on, to add to the 3rd party discount. .Also, different cities (and counties) have higher local taxes than others, which may add to your total cost.


focused
OC, CA
3 blogs/27 comments
since Nov 15 2005

Level 3
AttributeLevel
Overall3
Safety4
Compliance0
Integrity4
Reliability4
Karma4
See Photo Albums
Feb 16 2019 05:28PM     link to this

I used the Costco program. I paid $2200.00 below sticker price without haggling. I also got a $1500.00 manufacturer discount which helped with the sales tax. I don't know if I could have done better on my own without Costco's help, but I was satisfied with the whole process. Hope this helps.
dakegg
LA, CA
9 blogs/817 comments
since Jun 8 2006

Level 0
AttributeLevel
Overall0
Safety1
Compliance0
Integrity0
Reliability0
Karma1
Feb 16 2019 06:28PM     link to this

I was going to buy a car at Costco but I got a pizza instead. Not mad at my decision.
OCCityBoy2
OC, CA
27 blogs/2441 comments
since Jul 15 2016

Level 3
AttributeLevel
Overall3
Safety4
Compliance4
Integrity4
Reliability4
Karma4
See Photo Albums
Feb 16 2019 07:41PM     link to this

That service, which showed me the real dealer cost, is www.truecar.com

I got a car, for $3000 below sticker price.
Sure, it was a compact car, not super loaded.
Add in tax and license, still $1000 below sticker.

2nd car bought using www.truecar.com
ocguy66
OC, CA
45 blogs/1904 comments
since Apr 26 2006

Level 5
AttributeLevel
Overall5
Safety5
Compliance5
Integrity5
Reliability5
Karma5
See Photo Albums
Feb 16 2019 08:48PM     link to this

Good info. Thanks.
Facephuckker
Austin, TX
149 blogs/9751 comments
since Sep 10 2009

Level 4
AttributeLevel
Overall4
Safety5
Compliance5
Integrity4
Reliability4
Karma4
See Photo Albums
Feb 16 2019 08:56PM     link to this

a;ways ask for the employee discount, and start there
typically 50% below retail. i was a salesman at a gm dealership once, and just amazed how much the real markups and dealer incentives can get
ocguy66
OC, CA
45 blogs/1904 comments
since Apr 26 2006

Level 5
AttributeLevel
Overall5
Safety5
Compliance5
Integrity5
Reliability5
Karma5
See Photo Albums
Feb 16 2019 09:14PM     link to this

Good call.
bangkoklvr
City of Riverside, Inland Empire, CA
199 blogs/1092 comments
since Oct 14 2005

Level 4
AttributeLevel
Overall4
Safety4
Compliance3
Integrity4
Reliability4
Karma5
See Photo Albums
Feb 16 2019 09:52PM     link to this

I agree with burnsie1169. That is what I did on the last two 300zx cars I bought. Saved 2K on the first and 10K on the second. The last car I bought was via carmax. It had 4000 miles and still smelled brand new.

I pick the car I want and do some research on the average amount paid. Then I shoot for much less.
InsearchofStarfish
Santa Ana, OC, CA
741 blogs/13135 comments
since Nov 17 2008

Level 2
AttributeLevel
Overall2
Safety3
Compliance2
Integrity2
Reliability2
Karma3
See Photo Albums
Feb 16 2019 10:04PM     link to this

i would typically spend a few hrs looking at the lease deals figuring out the discount they were offering on the basic car..change and add my options to get a ball park in the lease menu...make sure you talk to at least two dealers.

when you do a build on the websites they don't factor in the discount so you need to figure what it is first whether it's lease or buy....but can figure it from their leases pretty easy

just for ball park purposes so you don't get hosed



YourCaptain
San Diego, CA
3 blogs/313 comments
since Jun 25 2010

Level 2
AttributeLevel
Overall2
Safety3
Compliance1
Integrity2
Reliability2
Karma3
See Photo Albums
Feb 16 2019 10:40PM     link to this

Truecar... got a Jeep for around 13% off msrp. Literally just showed up at the dealer with the printout generated on the site, did the paperwork and drove off. Probably the same at costco, etc.
ocguy66
OC, CA
45 blogs/1904 comments
since Apr 26 2006

Level 5
AttributeLevel
Overall5
Safety5
Compliance5
Integrity5
Reliability5
Karma5
See Photo Albums
Feb 16 2019 11:16PM     link to this

Thanks to all.... I think this will be a full court press..... 1 dealer, talk to the internet sales guy. 2nd dealer, use costco/truecar. 3rd dealer, just walk in and low ball them.
teeitup
Massachusetts
1017 blogs/14626 comments
since Jun 9 2007

Level 4
AttributeLevel
Overall4
Safety4
Compliance5
Integrity4
Reliability4
Karma4
See Photo Albums
Feb 16 2019 11:23PM     link to this

For a few thousand FX, I'll come with you dressed in a trench coat. Introduce me as your Sicilian friend Rocco whose not having a very good day.
ocguy66
OC, CA
45 blogs/1904 comments
since Apr 26 2006

Level 5
AttributeLevel
Overall5
Safety5
Compliance5
Integrity5
Reliability5
Karma5
See Photo Albums
Feb 16 2019 11:44PM     link to this

Trench coat = flasher
gee_mans
San Diego, CA
44 blogs/1044 comments
since Aug 24 2008

Level 4
AttributeLevel
Overall4
Safety4
Compliance4
Integrity4
Reliability4
Karma4
See Photo Albums
Feb 17 2019 12:00AM     link to this

Years ago, I used AAA and it was basically dealer’s invoice plus tax. No haggling needed. However, if you do your research and are good at haggling and negotiating, then that is your route.

Last new vehicle, I used CarProUSA’s buying program. It was much better and easier than AAA. Does not cost anything to use if one does not have Costco or AAA membership.

Good luck
dblednmike
Carson, Inland Cities, LA, CA
73 blogs/1375 comments
since Jan 28 2008

Level 3
AttributeLevel
Overall3
Safety3
Compliance0
Integrity3
Reliability3
Karma3
See Photo Albums
Feb 17 2019 07:50AM     link to this

Check out FightingChance.com, they are a great service that will provide all the dealer invoice pricing for what you’re looking for. They also also have a lot of free advice on how to get the best deals.

How good of a deal you get depends on how flexible you are too. If you have a very specific make, model, trim, and color you are going to have less negotiating power then if you are flexible on some areas.

As for the original question about Costco, and other discount programs. I know someone that looked at Costco and the buyer program from thier Credit Union after trying on thier own, and they did a better job then either one.
mcconnoisseur
LA, CA
278 blogs/2383 comments
since Apr 4 2009

Level 5
AttributeLevel
Overall5
Safety5
Compliance5
Integrity5
Reliability5
Karma5
See Photo Albums
Feb 17 2019 09:13AM     link to this

+1 truecar.

Helped a friend make a purchase of a popular model. Price quoted was much lower than market rate according to edmunds.

Made an appointment online, brought the print out from truecar, and we were done well less than 1 hour (no financing).

You might be able to save a few dollars if you want to haggle, but who needs the brain damage.

This was a few years ago so maybe there are better sites now.
ocguy66
OC, CA
45 blogs/1904 comments
since Apr 26 2006

Level 5
AttributeLevel
Overall5
Safety5
Compliance5
Integrity5
Reliability5
Karma5
See Photo Albums
Feb 17 2019 10:06AM     link to this

Any of youse want to hook me up with helpful Honda friends and family discount?
remo_williams
Irvine, OC, CA
16 blogs/1133 comments
since Feb 14 2006

Level 2
AttributeLevel
Overall2
Safety3
Compliance3
Integrity2
Reliability2
Karma3
See Photo Albums
Feb 17 2019 01:40PM     link to this

No one mentioned 'dealer holdback' - the dealer deserves to make a profit - but just because you THINK you paid XX above "invoice" does not make it so. Dealers have tons of ways to "cook the books".

My best advice is negotiate the price paid (out the door) - DO NOT negotiate monthly payments.

Just my two cents.
jimmmyz
OC, CA
118 blogs/1205 comments
since Feb 3 2014

Level 5
AttributeLevel
Overall5
Safety5
Compliance5
Integrity5
Reliability5
Karma5
See Photo Albums
Feb 18 2019 07:37AM     link to this

CarMax
sc12345sc
Orange, OC, CA
3 blogs/84 comments
since May 14 2009

Level 3
AttributeLevel
Overall3
Safety4
Compliance4
Integrity4
Reliability4
Karma3
See Photo Albums
Feb 18 2019 08:48AM     link to this

Used Costco to purchase 2 base model Yaris Toyotas for my company. $100 over sticker. Period, No haggling, in and out in 45 minutes....worked for me.
teeitup
Massachusetts
1017 blogs/14626 comments
since Jun 9 2007

Level 4
AttributeLevel
Overall4
Safety4
Compliance5
Integrity4
Reliability4
Karma4
See Photo Albums
Feb 18 2019 12:46PM     link to this

^^^Yaris? You work for Fubs, Inc.?
Facephuckker
Austin, TX
149 blogs/9751 comments
since Sep 10 2009

Level 4
AttributeLevel
Overall4
Safety5
Compliance5
Integrity4
Reliability4
Karma4
See Photo Albums
Feb 18 2019 01:55PM     link to this

isn't that like a limousine to a scrawny bird
Eyshinta
OC, CA
2 blogs/233 comments
since May 27 2007

Level 3
AttributeLevel
Overall3
Safety4
Compliance4
Integrity4
Reliability4
Karma4
Feb 23 2019 09:31AM     link to this

I always LOL when a car salesman tries to give me the "invoice price" or "employee discount." I tell them to go x% lower especially if when I'm buying a mass market car.

The dealership that actually paid "invoice price" for a car is the next one to close down.
jimmmyz
OC, CA
118 blogs/1205 comments
since Feb 3 2014

Level 5
AttributeLevel
Overall5
Safety5
Compliance5
Integrity5
Reliability5
Karma5
See Photo Albums
Feb 24 2019 06:23AM     link to this

Extra services when buying a car spell RIP-OFF.
Promoplex
Carlsbad, San Diego, CA
31 blogs/250 comments
since Jun 3 2009

Level 2
AttributeLevel
Overall2
Safety3
Compliance3
Integrity2
Reliability2
Karma3
See Photo Albums
Feb 24 2019 06:45PM     link to this

If haggling is the issue, Enterprise Used Car sales has a no haggling policy. What's on the sticker price is what you get.
There are 32 comments on this blog.