Contact Us/Help!
Handle:
Password:
Forget Your Password?    Join for FREE!
Nacraman
Santa Barbara, Central Coast, CA
87 blogs/3142 comments
since Feb 21 2009

Level 1
AttributeLevel
Overall1
Safety2
Compliance1
Integrity1
Reliability2
Karma2
See Photo Albums
Conception Dive Boat Owners File Lawsuit
Sep 7 2019 01:12PM more by Nacraman
Tags: Central Coast, Random (All tags)

Wow, so the owners of the Conception use some obscure 1851 Maritime Law to eliminate any liability. This has a lot of people pissed off, went to the memorial last night and afterwards a couple of my ocean buddies were pissed that they would even file this so soon. Grief turns to Anger!!!
Attached Links
https://www.latimes.com/california/story/2019-09-05/california-boat-fire-lawsuit-damages-court-filing
      
There are 20 comments on this blog.
Nacraman
Santa Barbara, Central Coast, CA
87 blogs/3142 comments
since Feb 21 2009

Level 1
AttributeLevel
Overall1
Safety2
Compliance1
Integrity1
Reliability2
Karma2
See Photo Albums
Sep 7 2019 01:22PM     link to this

The Marine Maritime Limitation of Liability Act of 1851, This fucking law should be repealed!

Either Way, because of this I will never use any boat from Truth Aquatics again...
Attached Links
https://www.maritimeprofessional.com/blogs/post/limitation-of-liability-act-of-1851-13234
Facephuckker
Austin, TX
149 blogs/9751 comments
since Sep 10 2009

Level 4
AttributeLevel
Overall4
Safety5
Compliance5
Integrity4
Reliability4
Karma4
See Photo Albums
Sep 7 2019 01:31PM     link to this

this is the state of kkkalifornia nowadays
mjcjmjcj
Burbank, SFV, LA, CA
24 blogs/8667 comments
since Jul 20 2013

Level 3
AttributeLevel
Overall3
Safety3
Compliance3
Integrity3
Reliability3
Karma3
See Photo Albums
Sep 7 2019 02:49PM     link to this

The KKK has taken over California?

The maritime law the case refers to is a federal law not a Californian one. But what do facts matter when the KKK control California. Lol
Nacraman
Santa Barbara, Central Coast, CA
87 blogs/3142 comments
since Feb 21 2009

Level 1
AttributeLevel
Overall1
Safety2
Compliance1
Integrity1
Reliability2
Karma2
See Photo Albums
Sep 7 2019 03:33PM     link to this

Yes, it's a Federal Law and they applied in this case, which was their right. But as one of my friends said they may have saved their business but they've destroyed their reputation...
sherkahn
Diamond Bar, SGV, LA, CA
Pomona, Inland Empire, CA Today!
1113 blogs/5529 comments
since Apr 27 2008

Level 2
AttributeLevel
Overall2
Safety2
Compliance3
Integrity3
Reliability3
Karma2
See Photo Albums
Sep 7 2019 04:08PM     link to this

If this is correct they may have now lost the business and lost any good will towards them.
Grumpy
Inland Empire, CA
256 blogs/9556 comments
since Sep 14 2006

Level 5
AttributeLevel
Overall5
Safety5
Compliance-2
Integrity5
Reliability5
Karma5
See Photo Albums
Sep 7 2019 04:12PM     link to this

They can always smuggle illegal immigrants from south of the border for business.
Nacraman
Santa Barbara, Central Coast, CA
87 blogs/3142 comments
since Feb 21 2009

Level 1
AttributeLevel
Overall1
Safety2
Compliance1
Integrity1
Reliability2
Karma2
See Photo Albums
Sep 7 2019 04:27PM     link to this

phyremedic,
You know I respect you. But in 2013 one of the boats in Truth Aquatics Fleet caught fire at the dock late one evening. Because it was in the harbor when it happened the night officer at the SB Harbor patrol saw the flames and the SB Fire unit was there in minutes but not before it torched the galley and bridge. The cause at that time was attributed to a marine radio charger that overheated and caught fire. What could have prevented, sure they had alarms and smoke detectors but why wasn't some form of fire suppression system installed after that.

I'm not a knee jerk liberal, far from it. But I saw the memorial at the SB Harbor of the people lost and especially the whole family of daughters, mother, and their father and asked why? Knowing that they've had fire before; Why wasn't more done. I'm not he only SB Diver/Surfer/Sailor asking the same questions...

They saved their business but destroyed their reputation
Nacraman
Santa Barbara, Central Coast, CA
87 blogs/3142 comments
since Feb 21 2009

Level 1
AttributeLevel
Overall1
Safety2
Compliance1
Integrity1
Reliability2
Karma2
See Photo Albums
Sep 7 2019 04:32PM     link to this

Unrelated in 2005 the Conception was stolen from the SB Harbor and motored all the way to Vandenberg AFB where it was ran aground





Attached Links
http://diver.net/bbs/messages/51433.shtml
socaliam
CA
4 blogs/2619 comments
since Sep 3 2007

Level 3
AttributeLevel
Overall3
Safety4
Compliance4
Integrity4
Reliability4
Karma4
See Photo Albums
Sep 7 2019 04:32PM     link to this

They = insurance company, etc. Not a cold-hearted owner action.
OCCityBoy2
OC, CA
27 blogs/2441 comments
since Jul 15 2016

Level 3
AttributeLevel
Overall3
Safety4
Compliance4
Integrity4
Reliability4
Karma4
See Photo Albums
Sep 7 2019 05:10PM     link to this

WHEN it is your time to MEET your maker,
be ready. YOU will go when it's YOUR hour.

people trapped below decks?

sounds fishy. family of 5?
Facephuckker
Austin, TX
149 blogs/9751 comments
since Sep 10 2009

Level 4
AttributeLevel
Overall4
Safety5
Compliance5
Integrity4
Reliability4
Karma4
See Photo Albums
Sep 7 2019 05:13PM     link to this

all the speculation in the world will not give any of us the answers. we all have to wait for the investigation to finish, then the outrage or not should begin
conjecture at this stage is pointless
InsearchofStarfish
Santa Ana, OC, CA
741 blogs/13135 comments
since Nov 17 2008

Level 2
AttributeLevel
Overall2
Safety3
Compliance2
Integrity2
Reliability2
Karma3
See Photo Albums
Sep 7 2019 05:18PM     link to this

the saw the rooms and beds...no fucking way ever ever ever ever...almost as bad as taking an MRI

just seeing the pictures on tv made me feel antsy


redbull09
San Luis Obispo, Central Coast, CA
54 blogs/805 comments
since Jul 26 2009

Level 3
AttributeLevel
Overall3
Safety4
Compliance4
Integrity4
Reliability4
Karma4
See Photo Albums
Sep 7 2019 07:24PM     link to this

I don't think you call what they did as filing a lawsuit. They filed for a ruling to limit liability payments. This had to be done before any of the relatives filed their lawsuits. The dive shop in my town said they have used this outfit for 25 years and claims it is the best for dive operations, and never a problem. Just the setup though for sleeping below with no way out needs to be updated though.
thedon60
Long Beach, LA, CA
2 blogs/1447 comments
since Sep 4 2008

Level 4
AttributeLevel
Overall4
Safety4
Compliance5
Integrity4
Reliability4
Karma4
See Photo Albums
Sep 7 2019 07:42PM     link to this

There are some reports the dead died of smoke inhalation. Does this show anything about the safety of the boat or cause of the fire. I am no expert so will defer as to whether this is significant at all. The best that come out of it are possibly increased safety precautions in the future.
MUNK
Lake Forest, OC, CA
736 blogs/21204 comments
since Feb 2 2013

Level 4
AttributeLevel
Overall4
Safety4
Compliance4
Integrity4
Reliability4
Karma4
See Photo Albums
Sep 7 2019 08:03PM     link to this

Someone should set their other boat on fire
hornitoss
San Clemente, OC, CA
8 blogs/220 comments
since Oct 29 2008

Level 1
AttributeLevel
Overall1
Safety2
Compliance0
Integrity2
Reliability1
Karma2
See Photo Albums
Sep 7 2019 08:55PM     link to this

A historical fact regarding ...
"The Marine Maritime Limitation of Liability Act of 1851" (MMLLA-1851)

The RMS Titanic was actually owned by a U.S. citizen.
Although the RMS Titanic was registered as a British ship, it was owned by the American, John Pierpont (J.P.) Morgan, whose company was the controlling trust and retained ownership of the White Star Line. He also owned US Steel, General Electric, as well as the global financial services firm JP Morgan Chase & Co which still thrives today.

When the Titanic sank in 1912, J.P. Morgan, invoked the MMLLA-1851 to limit his liability!

And who knows??? Had the MMLLA-1851 not been enacted, those of us who use Chase bank today might be using BofA or Wells Fargo ...
hornitoss
San Clemente, OC, CA
8 blogs/220 comments
since Oct 29 2008

Level 1
AttributeLevel
Overall1
Safety2
Compliance0
Integrity2
Reliability1
Karma2
See Photo Albums
Sep 7 2019 09:18PM     link to this

Although I have never been on an overnight dive boat, I have been on quite a few overnight trips on fishing boats. And on all the overnight boats I've been on, the bunks are below the main deck.

It is HORRIBLE trying to sleep in these bunks!!! But some HX'ers may like sleeping below deck where half the people are snoring so loudly that you might not be able to hear an alarm if one was ringing. And the snoring is not that bad when considering one other thing going on below deck ... THE FARTING!!! There's not a 30 second time gap where someone's blowin' out a fart!! And there's not a minute long gap where half the people below deck are blowin' out farts!!! And on these overnight albacore and/or mahi-mahi fishing trips, I was never able to sleep.

Considering that my farts were the only ones that smelled REALLY GOOD ... it's not a surprise I couldn't sleep. But thankfully there was never a risk of a fire, and freshly caught mahi-mahi is FANTASTIC!!
InsearchofStarfish
Santa Ana, OC, CA
741 blogs/13135 comments
since Nov 17 2008

Level 2
AttributeLevel
Overall2
Safety3
Compliance2
Integrity2
Reliability2
Karma3
See Photo Albums
Sep 7 2019 10:29PM     link to this

some of the best times we had to wade thru shit to get there...it just ain't happening in that type of environment/close quarters
lachineseguy
SGV, LA, CA
2021 blogs/18970 comments
since Mar 3 2006

Level 5
AttributeLevel
Overall5
Safety5
Compliance5
Integrity5
Reliability5
Karma5
See Photo Albums
Sep 8 2019 12:07AM     link to this

MGM did something similar too

https://www.nytimes.com/2018/07/17/us/mgm-resorts-sues-victims.html
Attached Links
https://www.nytimes.com/2018/07/17/us/mgm-resorts-sues-victims.html
inventor1948
Coastal, LA, CA
0 blogs/74 comments
since Aug 12 2006

Level 3
AttributeLevel
Overall3
Safety4
Compliance-1
Integrity3
Reliability4
Karma4
See Photo Albums
Sep 8 2019 12:29AM     link to this

Apparently by the mid-1800's, ship owners couldn't buy liability insurance, so the congress passed that maritime bill. And it's still on the books today and here we are. Titanic used it as well as oil tanker accidents and the big BP Horizon blow out in the Gulf in 2010.
There are 20 comments on this blog.