Contact Us/Help!
Handle:
Password:
Forget Your Password?    Join for FREE!
NinaChanel
City of San Diego, San Diego, CA
28 blogs/22 comments
since Jul 7 2014

Level 2
AttributeLevel
Overall2
Safety3
Compliance3
Integrity2
Reliability2
Karma2
See Photo Albums
Salt water fish tank vs fresh water fish tanks.
Nov 12 2020 07:17AM more by NinaChanel
Tags: San Diego , Random (All tags)

I really want to get a fish tank. Ive had fresh water fish before but Ive yet to own salt water fish. Therefore, Im skeptical about the care and maintenance of them. Does anyone have any general information they can help me with ?
      
There are 13 comments on this blog.
kuya_zoom
WY
51 blogs/670 comments
since Mar 31 2020

Level 0
AttributeLevel
Overall0
Safety0
Compliance0
Integrity0
Reliability0
Karma1
See Photo Albums
Nov 12 2020 07:21AM     link to this

I've had a salt water tanks before. Marine tanks are absolutely beautiful and its a fun hobby, but its a lot of work. Don't take it on if you're willing to spend a lot of time and money to keep it maintained.
kuya_zoom
WY
51 blogs/670 comments
since Mar 31 2020

Level 0
AttributeLevel
Overall0
Safety0
Compliance0
Integrity0
Reliability0
Karma1
See Photo Albums
Nov 12 2020 07:22AM     link to this

Errr...I meant NOT willing
Harpooner
Inland Empire, CA
173 blogs/944 comments
since Oct 12 2006

Level 3
AttributeLevel
Overall3
Safety3
Compliance4
Integrity3
Reliability3
Karma3
See Photo Albums
Nov 12 2020 07:39AM     link to this

Consider going with African cichlids instead. They are fresh water fish but nearly as colorful as saltwater. Much easier to care for and they reproduce like crazy.
Its.All.Good
Murrieta, Inland Empire, CA
48 blogs/2284 comments
since Mar 31 2014

Level 4
AttributeLevel
Overall4
Safety4
Compliance3
Integrity4
Reliability4
Karma4
See Photo Albums
Nov 12 2020 07:40AM     link to this

Salt Water tanks require a lot more maintenance and cleaning, and you don't want those fish dying as they are much more expensive!
kuya_zoom
WY
51 blogs/670 comments
since Mar 31 2020

Level 0
AttributeLevel
Overall0
Safety0
Compliance0
Integrity0
Reliability0
Karma1
See Photo Albums
Nov 12 2020 07:51AM     link to this

A fish ONLY saltwater tank is easier than a reef tank, but still more work than a fresh water tank. A reef tank, with live corals and invertebrates require tons of time and effort, but reef tanks are way more beautiful and interesting than a fish only tank.
NPembrush
Lake Forest, OC, CA
50 blogs/1338 comments
since Jul 19 2018

Level 0
AttributeLevel
Overall0
Safety0
Compliance0
Integrity0
Reliability0
Karma0
See Photo Albums
Nov 12 2020 08:31AM     link to this

Do lots of research. Like freshwater you have specialized tanks for inverts (snails, starfish, crabs etc), reef tanks (absolutely beautiful...) and fish.

If you can keep a health freshwater tank for a long time (years) you can start with a fish only salt water tank (starter tank for salt). Avoid reef tanks at first since they are super finicky about water conditions and you may buy some animals that find your $100 coral you just bought as a wonderful snack.

As noted above salt tanks require more attention that freshwater...although I disagree, even freshwater tanks take lots of attention because if you don't you end up with a swamp and/or dead fish. Salt tanks are just way more expensive to setup and maintain.
FlappyNutSack
OC, CA
177 blogs/2785 comments
since Sep 30 2020

Level 3
AttributeLevel
Overall3
Safety3
Compliance4
Integrity4
Reliability4
Karma3
See Photo Albums
Nov 12 2020 08:43AM     link to this

I've had both. My experience is that after the salt water tank has time to adjust and is "in equilibrium" that the fish taste better than from the fresh water tank.
DGeo000
North of LA, LA, CA
1 blogs/30 comments
since Mar 31 2014

Level 1
AttributeLevel
Overall1
Safety2
Compliance2
Integrity2
Reliability2
Karma2
See Photo Albums
Nov 12 2020 08:52AM     link to this

I would recommend minimum 40 to 50 gal salt water tank to start... this will help buffer any mistakes you make in regards to water chemistry. And start with few blue damsels first until you gain some experience. Feeding live anemones are a blast though 😊
NPembrush
Lake Forest, OC, CA
50 blogs/1338 comments
since Jul 19 2018

Level 0
AttributeLevel
Overall0
Safety0
Compliance0
Integrity0
Reliability0
Karma0
See Photo Albums
Nov 13 2020 12:52AM     link to this

Heh...so I'm not the only fish tank junky here. 😁
osssieboy
City of San Diego, San Diego, CA
34 blogs/82 comments
since Feb 5 2013

Level 1
AttributeLevel
Overall1
Safety2
Compliance2
Integrity2
Reliability2
Karma2
See Photo Albums
Nov 30 2020 08:58PM     link to this

I've had both saltwater and freshwater tanks over the years. If you're starting out, I'd suggest getting a freshwater tank. Planted tanks are really great and I tend to focus on them. For that you need a good light and CO2 as well as fertilizer. And don't get fish that eat plants. Saltwater tanks are beautiful but require more investment of money and time. I'd suggest looking up some inspiration on IG and also joining a few groups on Facebook. You can get a lot of great information that way. Also, on Facebook marketplace there are often some really great bargains for aquariums and supplies. The key factors are getting a tank that's big enough for what you want, and getting fish that are compatible too.
ultimatejohn
Dana Point, OC, CA
214 blogs/734 comments
since Sep 17 2017

Level 2
AttributeLevel
Overall2
Safety3
Compliance2
Integrity3
Reliability3
Karma3
See Photo Albums
Dec 2 2020 08:19AM     link to this

If you know what you're doing saltwater is actually easier and WAY more interesting and beautiful. It takes a little chemistry and 50 gal is the absolutely the smallest plus ultraviolet sterilization unit. Fresh isn't even worth it in my opinion. Just get a guppy if you go fresh
Allison_Snow
Temecula, Inland Empire, CA
225 blogs/968 comments
since Aug 15 2008

Level 3
AttributeLevel
Overall3
Safety3
Compliance-1
Integrity3
Reliability3
Karma3
See Photo Albums
Dec 2 2020 11:46AM     link to this

I love a salt water tank but as everyone is saying its a lot of work and maintenance but so worth it.
NPembrush
Lake Forest, OC, CA
50 blogs/1338 comments
since Jul 19 2018

Level 0
AttributeLevel
Overall0
Safety0
Compliance0
Integrity0
Reliability0
Karma0
See Photo Albums
Dec 2 2020 02:21PM     link to this

Freshwater tanks are boring? Says someone who probably only kept guppies! I've kept trout, sting rays, several species of freshwater puffer fish (including one that hides in the sand as an ambush predator), a huge tank of very colorful cichlids...

Still yeah a proper reef tank is far more beautiful, takes lots of experience but worth it if you love keeping fish.

There are 13 comments on this blog.